Monday, November 16, 2026

Still remembering Herbert Blomstedt: Let's finish up our Schubert and Bruckner "units"

Here at Sunday Classics we always aim for historical accuracy. It's
firmly established how Schubert was a lifelong lethargic layabout.


SCHUBERT: Symphony No. 8 in B minor (Unfinished), D. 759:
i. Allegro moderato
ii. Andante con moto [at 11:30]

[24:09] Staatskapelle Dresden, Herbert Blomstedt, cond. Deutsche Schallplatten, recorded in the Lukaskirche, Feb. 23-24, 1978

by Ken

In yesterday's post (What a difference 40 years (okay, 40½) can make!) focusing on Herbert Blomstedt's 1978-81 and 2021 recordings of the Schubert Eighth and Ninth Symphonies, we read -- from Tobias Niederschlag's booklet note for the 2021 Leipzig-DG recording -- the maestro's response to Tobias's question as to how his view of these symphonies had changed since he recorded them as part of the Dresden Schubert symphony cycle.

Up above we hear the whole of the 1978 Unfinished. Since we were concerned yesterday with the two recordings of the Great C major Symphony, let's now revisit the start of Maestro B.'s response to Tobias's question, where he targets the Unfinished. Just how had his view changed over those 40-plus years? (By way of reminder, he was 50 -- okay, call it 50½ -- at the time of the earlier recording, 94 at the time of the later one.)
It has changed a lot! Back then we still used the old complete edition of Schubert’s works – the volumes devoted to the symphonies had been edited by Johannes Brahms. The world owes Brahms a great deal for his work on these scores, but this old edition is flawed in many respects. We have known this ever since the New Schubert Edition began to appear with its extensive critical commentaries. In the ‘Unfinished’ Symphony, for example, there are a couple of astonishing dissonances before the opening movement’s recapitulation and also at the end of it. Believ­ing that Schubert was in error here, Brahms simply ‘smoothed’ these out. But these dissonances emerge logically from the work – and the new edition invests these passages with a completely different character.
Let's listen now to the 2021 first movement.

SCHUBERT: Symphony No. 8 in B minor (Unfinished), D. 759:
i. Allegro moderato

[14:42] Gewandhaus Orchestra (Leipzig), Herbert Blomstedt, cond. DG, recorded in the COVID-cleared Gewandhaus, November 2021


NOW LET'S FINISH UP ONE OTHER PIECE OF UNFINISHED
BUSINESS: FINISHING THE BRUCKNER SEVENTH SYMPHONY



I mentioned in the first "Blomstedt remembrance" post that for me the 1980 Blomstedt-Dresden Bruckner 7 has gratifying echoes of the beautiful recording Bruno Walter made in the last series of recordings he made, in Los Angeles with the pickup orchestra passed off as one of the many "Columbia Symphony Orchestra's. It's not exactly the kind of can-do-it-all orchestra we look for in prime Bruckner. But at this point in his life Walter could make that matter less than the soul he could inspire in the players. We've got the first two movements of that Bruckner 7 in the SC Archive. I thought we could dust them off to rehear, and then rehear the first two movements of the 1980 Blomstedt Bruckner 7, this time finishing them off with the Scherzo and Finale.

BRUCKNER: Symphony No. 7 in E:
i. Allegro moderato
ii. Adagio -- Sehr feierlich und sehr langsam (Very solemn
and very slow)
[at 20:51]

[40:15] Columbia Symphony Orchestra, Bruno Walter, cond. Columbia-CBS-Sony, recorded in the American Legion Hall, Hollywood, Mar. 11-21, 1961

BRUCKNER: Symphony No. 7 in E:
i. Allegro moderato
ii. Adagio -- Sehr feierlich und sehr langsam (Very solemn
and very slow)
[at 21:10]

iii. Scherzo: Schnell (Fast)
iv. Finale: Bewegt, doch nicht schnell (With movement, but
not too fast)
[at 9:40]

[45:38; 22:03] Staatskapelle Dresden, Herbert Blomstedt, cond. Denon-Deutsche Schall­platten, recorded in Studio Lukaskirche, June 30-July 3, 1980


QUICK THOUGHTS ABOUT THE SCHUBERT-BRUCKNER LINK

Thinking suddenly about Schubert and Bruckner in the same thought unit, and specifically Schubert 9 and Bruckner 7, got me, um, thinking. I wrote a whole long section of stuff, then wrote some more, and finally decided to keep it to myself, including the observation that Bruckner's Unfinished Symphony, the three-movement No. 9:

(1) may be unfinished for similar reasons as Schubert 8 (again there are sketches for an additional movement, which well-meaning enthusiasts try inexhaustibly to make something out of, but the fact remains that Bruckner couldn't -- and the reason may not be any darned pussycat); and --

(2) seems to me in its "unfinished" form just as complete as Schubert 8.

(Wait, I was supposed to be keeping that to myself. Did I say it out loud?)

Let me just leave you with this thought: Schubert and Bruckner. Maybe in particular the first two movements of Schubert 9 and Bruckner 7.

I'm sure I'm not the first listener to think about a Schubert-and-Bruckner connection. But I don't think it looms large in the consciousness of the Bruckner Faithful. (Do I have to spell out that I'm not a card-carrying member of the B.F.?) I'm thinking that Bruckner never stopped hearing Schubert in his head. And two thoughts occurred to me. The first is stupid: that maybe this might help differentiate Bruckner and Mahler. The problem: Schubert was if anything more deeply lodged in Mahler's head. The somewhat smarter thought: that this connection may be in some way connected to the link in my head between Herbert B.'s Bruckner 7 and Bruno W.'s.

Think about it.


WE'RE STILL NOT DONE WITH MAESTRO B.

As I mentioned last time, there's still an installment coming that will take us, among other places, into Herbert B.'s San Francisco years. Among the considerable goodies Decca produced are such things as the complete symphonies of two Scandinavian cousins of his, Denmark's Carl Nielsen and Finland's Jean Sibelius. The "pan-Scandinavian tour" will also include Norway's Edvard Grieg -- and maybe even a Swede! Franz Berwald, perhaps? I'm really not on a first-name basis with his music, but maybe now is the time. (Might this not please Maestro B?) I feel as if we should have something Swedish.) Plus we have Richard Strauss's deeply introspective Metamorphosen on tap, and I forget what-all-else. Maybe things I haven't even thought of yet!

SERIES NOTE: The "Blomstedt remembrance" tour has taken such an odd path, or paths, that when I have a chance I'm going to construct a box that will contain links to all the posts, to be appended to each.
#

No comments:

Post a Comment