Showing posts with label Colas Breugnon. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Colas Breugnon. Show all posts
Monday, November 22, 2021
Pre-post: Can we do a better job assembling the three movements of this symphony than, you know, the guy who composed them?
LET'S PUT TOGETHER OUR OWN SYMPHONY!
(By juggling the movements of this 1943 broadcast performance)
(1)
Here's the thing in "traditional" fast-slow-fast configuration:
i. Allegro || ii. Largo [at 6:38] || iii. Presto [at 28:06]
(2)
Here, the short quick movements lead up to the big slow one:
i. Allegro || ii. Presto [at 6:38] || iii. Largo [at 14:02]
(3)
Or, start with the giant movement, then tack on the 'quickies':
i. Largo || ii. Allegro [at 21:32] || iii. Presto [at 28:10]
by Ken
Haven't we all had the itch at some time to rejigger some or all of the movements of some symphony or other? Thinking, you know, that we can do a better assembly job than the person whose only authority was having composed the damned things?
This is basically what I've played at doing above, with a symphony that has the strangest structure of any I can think of from the pen of what I'm going to call a "serious symphonist," as anyone who approaches the piece for the first time is bound to notice quickly: three movements, with a slow movement that is considerably longer than the two fast movements put together. Many readers will recognize this symphony. For those who don't, I should disclose at the outset that in this "pre-post" I'm not going to disclose the identity of either the composer or the work -- a little experiment I'm hoping will be more interesting, even fun, for those who don't recognize the symphony. (For anyone who feels cheated, I would suggest that by pre-post's end, enough information will have been disclosed to enable online searchers to track the piece down in a minute or two.
BY CLICKING THROUGH TO THE PRE-POST
JUMP, THE READER WILL BE ABLE TO:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
